How do consumer contracts deal with copyright and data on the Internet of Things? That’s the question Jules Bélanger, Mohit Sethi, and I addressed in a report prepared for the Government of Canada.
The growth of the Internet of Things (IoT) has the potential to generate a number of issues related to copyright law. At the heart of the matter is the copyright-protected software integrated in connected objects. Innovation, Science and Economic Development Canada commissioned Option consommateurs to do a study to help better understand the challenges posed by the IoT to copyright law. The objective of the study was to gather relevant findings from the analysis of legal documentation, such as end-user license agreements, from a sample of connected IoT products, and highlight issues that could impact Canadian consumers in the years to come. The report identifies a number of copyright related restrictions, and brings to light several issues beyond copyright that merit consideration, such as competition, data portability and privacy. The report concludes with a number public policy recommendations regarding those issues.
Jules Bélanger, Jeremy de Beer, and Mohit Sethi, Consumer-related Copyright Issues on the Internet of Things: A Study of Connected Objects Available to Canadian Consumers, (2019) Innovation, Science and Economic Development Canada.
The Canadian Journal of Law and Technology published a peer reviewed version of our article in late 2020.
The article presents our interdisciplinary analysis of end-user license agreements and privacy policies from a sample of 22 consumer goods/services connected to the Internet of Things (IoT). We gathered data in the form of legal documents and assessed them from legal and economic perspectives. We developed an original taxonomy of IoT-connected consumer goods/services, classified different business models built around them, and reviewed legal terms and conditions related to their use.
Our analysis identifies copyright related restrictions and brings to light issues beyond copyright that merit consideration in the context of a review of copyright law and policy. First, we find that even obtaining legal information on smart products, including software license restrictions and other copyright limitations, is a difficult and time-consuming exercise. Second, our analysis of business models shows interoperability of platforms within an ecosystem of third-party devices and applications, but restrictions that limit interoperability across ecosystems. Third, terms and conditions of consumer use of smart devices in our sample are set up to allow for the collection and transfer of personal data, often sensitive data, in addition to all data collected by the companies from other sources such as social media. Fourth, our study shows that software licensing is now common practice among smart device manufacturers.
Based on these findings, we make recommendations to address the issues of
accessibility of legal information, data portability, interoperability of systems, and competition. We recommend that governments cooperate with industry, consumer, and public interest groups to: (1) promote labelling standards to help consumers locate and understand the terms on which they acquire and use IoT products and services; (2) support open standards and protocols to facilitate interoperability across platforms; (3) integrate data portability and related issues with ongoing discussions about not only copyright reform but also reforms to privacy laws and other digital rights; and (4) take seriously the relevant recommendations of the Parliamentary Committee for revision to the Copyright Act.
Suggested Citation: Jeremy de Beer, Jules Bélanger, and Mohit Sethi, “Consumer Contracts, Copyright Licensing, and Control Over Data on the Internet of Things” (2020) 18 Can J L & Tech 161.
Image credit: Wilgengebroed on Flickr, CC BY 2.0 https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0, via Wikimedia Commons.